Amalie Arena, part ii, building a better city

Anyone with a camera could walk around Amalie Arena in Tampa and make the case for successful city building: long vistas, lush landscaping, waterfront restaurants, bike trail access — catch a game, look at some fish, go for a cruise or stroll back to Hotel High and Monumental. Classic planner porn. Shown below are pic from the main arena plaza with the Ford garage on the right. Beyond its nice foreground facade, it became a much plainer parking deck. And what’s that beside it, on the left? An entire city block sized surface parking lot.  I hope it is temporary, … Continue reading Amalie Arena, part ii, building a better city

Amalie Arena, part i, an attractive downtown arena

Amalie Arena is located in the Chanelside district of downtown Tampa. It is home to the Tampa Bay Lightening NHL team. Built in 1996, is one of a long row of civic-urban-image buildings — the Aquarium, the cruise ship port, the history museum, the arena, the convention centre, two large hotels. The landscaping along the waterfront consists of broad walkways and cycling paths. The scale of everything is HUGE. The approach to the main entrance plaza is shown above. There were a number of statuary tributes to players and events. The plaza is elevated above a sunken street that runs … Continue reading Amalie Arena, part i, an attractive downtown arena

Amway Center, part iii, is it a catalyst for urban neighbourhoods?

Thus far in this series we have walked around the Amway Center and checked out the streets and garages around the complex. Let’s go a bit further out, and see how an urban arena relates to the downtown and surrounding neighbourhoods. Is the glamorous new urban arena a spark for a downtown urban renaissance?   (above) Immediately south of the arena lies the downtown high rises. Orlando’s isn’t a big downtown, it is quite compact. There are a dozen or so highrise apartment buildings and office towers, then a much wider periphery of lower rise commercial buildings with short parking structures or … Continue reading Amway Center, part iii, is it a catalyst for urban neighbourhoods?

Amway Center (part ii) adjacent streets and parking

above: people wishing to walk to the Amway Center from the downtown must use several widely-spaced apart streets that go under the elevator i4 freeway, its access ramps, and interchange with another freeway. The space is humanized in a select high traffic areas, such as where South Street goes under the freeways, with fountains, planters, and lighting. Other areas were parking spaces and much less open as there were not available “skylighting” gaps. above: There are approx 18 traffic lanes between the downtown (to the right) and the Center (shown to the left) which had to be crossed at grade or … Continue reading Amway Center (part ii) adjacent streets and parking

What a New Senator’s Arena could look like on LeBreton Flats

We have seen photoshops of what the Senator’s old arena, Canadian Tire Place, could look like if moved to LeBreton Flats. But what would a new arena actually look like? How could it be integrated into a new urban community? On your behalf, your faithful correspondent did some field research.  For the next week or more, lets look closely at Amway Arena (the Magics and Solar Bears, Orlando) and Amelie Arena (Tampa Bay Lighting).  Let’s look at the architecture of an urban arena, the surrounding neighbourhoods, and of course, the parking. First up:  Amway Arena, Orlando, Florida Exterior views:   … Continue reading What a New Senator’s Arena could look like on LeBreton Flats

More Proof People Who Cycle are Cheap Dates

What’s odd about the illustration above?  It shows a residential street with a lane for people who ride bikes. There are also sidewalks for people who walk. Look at the opposite side of the street. There is a double yellow line quite close to the curb. It isn’t a trick of the camera angle or a feature of my poor photo skills. The double yellow line shows the centre line of the road. People who drive have the central portion. People who cycle have a demarked lane if they are going in the same direction as people who drive. People who … Continue reading More Proof People Who Cycle are Cheap Dates

Proof People Who Cycle are Cheap Dates

People who walk or cycle want infrastructure improvements. Fortunately these improvements are cheap compared to facilities for people who drive motor cars. More cycling and pedestrian infrastructure isn’t an extravagance or luxury in a city budget, it’s a bargain. Repeat: people who walk or cycle are cheap dates. Pretty much all residential streets in the US and Canada built since the 1940’s lack facilities for people who walk. We just decided to ignore them and their needs in favour of people who drive cars. In the west side of Ottawa, this is generally true anywhere west of Churchill Avenue. Now look … Continue reading Proof People Who Cycle are Cheap Dates

Fix it yourself nice-ness

  I have come across several fix-it-yourself bike stations. The gesture and tools is really nice. And it probably saves the bike rental company from a lot of nuisance beggars at the door expecting free minor repairs.   I’ve come across similar tool sets in Cambridge, MA;   on Cape Cod    and Salzburg:. But not yet in Ottawa, although there is a non-public one behind St Andrew tower. This is at a time when gas stations increasingly charge cyclists for air, although the most egregious insult came when I found an air pump at a local gas station fill-er-up island that … Continue reading Fix it yourself nice-ness

Observing exteriors in Hintonburg

There is still infill going on in Hintonburg. Lots of it. Silver corrugated cladding, sometimes accented with black siding, is lowly giving way to new expressions.   Here, for example, some infills have bright coloured panels: I’m a sucker for colour, so I love these. And a bit further down the block, there are some bent metal claddings with some red corrugated sections. And on The Eddy, a six storey apartment building on Wellington at Spadina,  the exterior is covered in bright flat metal planks, with some accents of red. These look OK, but they are not what I remember … Continue reading Observing exteriors in Hintonburg

Welcome to West Side Action

Regular readers  [thank you !] of WestSideAction know this is a blog with stories about planning, transportation, cyling, pedestrians, and events on the west side of the downtown. People living and working outside that area have been known to read it from time to time. The Ottawa cultural affairs blog Apt613  asked me to do a story for them on the similarities of redevelopment of Lansdowne Park to the Sens moving to LeBreton Flats.  The result is a single article that is extracted from my Building LeBetter Flats series. It kicks off a series of stories about the future of Ottawa. … Continue reading Welcome to West Side Action

Rare unplanned-for-event at the transit station …

Readers of yesterday’s story might get the impression I was unenthused about the design of the Preston extension and LeBreton temporary transit station. You’d be right. Now we all know it snows in Ottawa. Sometimes a lot. So I am sure the planning boffins ran their fingers over the paved road shoulder “sidewalks” and the platforms at LeBreton Station and the walking required to get from platform to platform, or neighbourhood to platform. And then imagined how they  could be plowed. And then coordinated with the snow plow folks to ensure the stations and their access were plowed early, plowed … Continue reading Rare unplanned-for-event at the transit station …

Temporary transit station puts cars first, part 2

Yesterday, we looked at the car-first infrastructure at the Lyon LRT station entrance. Money appears to be available to spend on cars, but not pedestrians, even when building transit infrastructure. This save-a-penny attitude, when it comes to pedestrians, prevails in the city’s rail implementation office. Down on the Flats, Preston was recently extended out to the War Museum. The extension is temporary. It is wise to be frugal when building throw-away infrastructure, as this road will be rolled up and trashed in two years. But the penny pinching didn’t include narrower car lanes. No siree, they are full width, and the … Continue reading Temporary transit station puts cars first, part 2

Fostering transit by catering to cars (part 1)

Too often I cringe in dismay at the 99% motorist-focus of our planning and engineering staff. Do [m]any of the staff and consultants working on the LRT stations actually use transit? I have been known to cause moments of embarrassment by asking at an OTrain planning meeting if any staff present have actually ridden the train. [answer: rarely]. It’s quite easy to tell the station planners don’t walk to stations. Ever. Or take transit to work anywhere else, for that matter. Here’s a small example of how even when building and designing a state-of-the-art rapid transit system (ie, the Confederation … Continue reading Fostering transit by catering to cars (part 1)

Preston, streetcar, rezoning

The photo shows a streetcar on Preston, running northwards towards to Albert Street (then called Wellington). The photograph is taken from the corner of Elm at Preston, looking south.  The store in the background is still there, now it houses Pubwells, at the corner of Spruce. The thinner pole holding a guywire on the left seems to be a streetcar rail uprighted and embedded into the pavement. Some cobblestones peek through the asphalt at the crosswalk. After tearing them all out, in favour of smooth road surfaces of asphalt,  the City reinstalled paver stone crosswalks in 2011. Beyond the buildings … Continue reading Preston, streetcar, rezoning

Rochester Fields Forever

With all the fuss about the extreme dangers of LRT service in a shallow tunnel along the western parkway, it is sometimes useful to remember what was there in the recent past. This photo shows the last freight train (1967) going along the tracks between Rochester Field and the River.  The photograph is taken from near Richmond Road, looking north. Here’s another shot, from further west,  taken from Carling Avenue, looking down Maplehurst towards the Parkway. Notice the small cottages on the right. The For Sale sign notes “no more trains”, presumably raising the property value. Continue reading Rochester Fields Forever

Somerset Viaduct in history

On the last day of streetcar service in Ottawa in May 1959, a farewell parade was held of equipment and personalities. This picture is taken from the crest of the Somerset Viaduct, right at what is now the OTrain Trillium Line overpass. Slightly downhill to the right the white building is now a Buddhist Temple; St Jean Baptiste priory can be see silhouetted on the left horizon; Preston Street runs across Somerset at the bottom of the hill. Double click the picture to enlarge it. Notice the very decorative  railing on the left, just visible between the parked cars. And … Continue reading Somerset Viaduct in history

Extending the OTrain Trillium Line South to Airport / Riverside South

The City has been planning for quite some time to extend the existing OTrain Trillium Line further south, from Greenboro to Leitrim or Bowes Road. They will be holding public meetings on all the changes required and plans, on Jan 13 at Durrell Rec Centre, and Jan 15th, 6-8pm, at St Anthony Hall. I encourage anyone with an interest to go and support the extended service. And press for its early start. Currently, the red trainsets run every 15 minutes. There are two trains in operation at any one time on the single-track line, passing each other in the middle … Continue reading Extending the OTrain Trillium Line South to Airport / Riverside South

Building a Better LeBreton, part 9, Walking Portland’s SouthWaterfront streets

  The South Waterfront neighbourhood is very well landscaped. Intensively landscaped, with interesting bits of planters, plants, gardens, courtyards, and squares tucked into the smallest corners. The contrast to Ottawa’s LeBreton Flats couldn’t be stronger. Some of this may be due to a milder climate in Oregon. Or a project that has had vegetation in the ground and growing for longer. Or maybe a much more generous budget for greenery. The Flats look good on paper, and on the ground the “right elements” are laid out, but the execution makes me wince and thus far is poorly maintained. The City has … Continue reading Building a Better LeBreton, part 9, Walking Portland’s SouthWaterfront streets

Building LeBetter Flats, part 8, Portland South Waterfront residential buildings

The NCC chose for the Flats a model of lowish podiums (7 stories) with mid rise towers above (another 7 stories, 14 floors in total). Portland’s South Waterfront is decidedly much more highrise. It is, no doubt, what Ottawa planners have wet dreams about when they imagine the Preston-Carling area in 30 years time with its snowstorm of highrises. I very much doubt we will achieve that. I gather the NCC and Claridge are negotiating to abandon the rest of the existing low and mid rise LeBreton Flats plan (east of Booth Street) to build much taller towers on the remaining … Continue reading Building LeBetter Flats, part 8, Portland South Waterfront residential buildings

Building LeBetter Flats, part 7, the view from Portland

Portland, Oregon, is often referred to as a city that has gone further with “Smart Growth” than other cities. It promotes transit by train, streetcar, bike, and aerial tram. It has numerous award winning downtown parks and redevelopment sites. IMO, its planning reputation and branding sometimes exceeds its delivery. One site in particular is comparable to LeBreton Flats in terms of location (just outside the downtown core, on former industrial lands), although Portland’s South Waterfront is twice the area (402 acres vs NCC’s <200 acres). Portland’s has room to expand as it takes over adjacent industrial users; the NCC’s site … Continue reading Building LeBetter Flats, part 7, the view from Portland

Building LeBetter Flats, part 6, The Sens again, with Plan B

If all that overindulgence in food and sweets still permits, recall the story a short while ago about the Senators moving to LeBreton Flats.  https://www.westsideaction.ca/lebetter-flats-part-3-senators-go-marching/ As I pointed out then, it makes much more sense for a new hockey palace to go west of Preston rather than close to Booth. Reasons? It would be adjacent the major station (Bayview) where the east-west Confederation Line crosses the north-south Trillium line (formerly known as the OTrain). The Prince of Wales former railway bridge over to Gatineau is supposed to have a cantilevered bike and ped path on it by 2018, according to our … Continue reading Building LeBetter Flats, part 6, The Sens again, with Plan B

Building LeBetter Flats, part 5, The Isles

The projected build out of Albert and Chaudiere Islands * starts with the material already at hand, ie the existing buildings. The former brick and stone mill buildings will be converted to commercial uses, starting in 2015. These offer the quickest revenue opportunity for the developer, Windmill, and I imagine it is much easier to attract firms rather than condo residents. Particularly hi-tech-y firms which show a propensity to edgy industrial sites in other cities in part due to their often young employee age group and non-conventional self-image. The first buildings to be converted will most likely be on Albert … Continue reading Building LeBetter Flats, part 5, The Isles

Building LeBetter Flats, part 4, Distillery & the Isles

That the general public’s view of the current LeBreton build out is less than unenthusiastic is beyond dispute. What is unsetting is how uninformed those views are since they are the too often the product of drive-by planning. As shown in Part 1 of Building LeBetter Flats, actually walking the site, even with landscaping only partially done, yields a much better experience. More amazing is the quick public grab onto the proposed project by Windmill Developments for the adjacent islands in the Ottawa River and the Gatineau shoreline.  It will be wonderful *, more like the magic Distillery District in … Continue reading Building LeBetter Flats, part 4, Distillery & the Isles